Academia Publishing Hub

Ontological Foundations of Human Rights in the Context of the Functioning of International Legal Mechanisms for Their Protection

← Усі матеріали збірника Тези доповіді

Ontological Foundations of Human Rights in the Context of the Functioning of International Legal Mechanisms for Their Protection

Oleksandr GvozdiyKhmelnytskyi University of Management and Law named after Leonid Yuzkov, Khmelnytskyi, Ukraine
КонференціяМіжнародна наукова конференція “Interdisciplinary Studies, Innovation and Society”
Дата02.11.2026
Сторінки64–68
ОрганізаторAcademia Publishing Hub

Анотація

The paper examines the ontological status of human rights in the context of the functioning of international legal mechanisms for their protection. It argues that human rights exist as what ought to be, not as what is, and that no jurisdiction in the world ensures their full realisation. Drawing on the distinction between “is” and “ought” (D. Hume, H. Kelsen) and on the critique of natural rights (J. Bentham), it is shown that the existence of a valid norm is not equivalent to the existence of a right as a fact. International protection mechanisms, in particular the European Court of Human Rights, operate in the gap between the norm and reality, and their effectiveness depends on the willingness of states to comply with judgments, as illustrated by the expulsion of the Russian Federation from the Council of Europe. It is concluded that the proclamation of a right must be distinguished from the conditions of its realisation: an independent judiciary, enforcement of judgments, accountability for violations and political will.

Ключові слова

human rights; “is” and “ought”; ontology of law; international legal protection; European Court of Human Rights; enforcement of judgments.

Як цитувати (ДСТУ 8302:2015)

Gvozdiy O. Ontological Foundations of Human Rights in the Context of the Functioning of International Legal Mechanisms for Their Protection. Interdisciplinary Studies, Innovation and Society : Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference / Academia Publishing Hub (Utrecht, 2 November 2026). Utrecht, 2026. P. 64–68. DOI: 10.64076/ap261102.10.

Сертифікати учасників